Garfield County: The Most Difficult Place to Buy a Home in the U.S., Per NBC News

Stephanie Kroll

If you're in the market for a home in Carbondale of Glenwood Springs, you've likely encountered numerous challenges, from soaring prices to intense competition. However, nowhere is this more evident than in Garfield County, Colorado, which has been named the #1 most difficult and competitive county in the country to buy a home, according to NBC News.

Why Is It So Hard to Buy a Home?

Several factors contribute to the difficulty of buying a home in today’s market:

  • High Prices: Home prices have far outpaced middle-class incomes, making affordability a significant issue.
  • High Mortgage Rates: With mortgage rates above 7% for the first time since 2002, financing a home purchase has become more expensive.
  • Competitive Market: Approximately 30% of homes are sold above their listing price, indicating intense competition among buyers.

Introducing the NBC News Home Buyer Index

To better understand and capture the shifting conditions of the housing market at the local level, NBC News has developed the Home Buyer Index. This index, created with insights from real estate industry analysts and economists, measures the difficulty potential buyers face when trying to purchase a home. The index ranges from 0 to 100, with higher values indicating greater difficulty.

Factors Measured by the Home Buyer Index

The index evaluates four main factors:

  1. Cost: This considers how much homes cost relative to incomes and inflation, as well as changes in related expenses like insurance costs.
  2. Competition: This measures the number of people vying for homes and the intensity of demand, including the percentage of homes sold above list price and how quickly homes go under contract.
  3. Scarcity: This looks at the number of homes available on the market and the expected inventory in the coming month.
  4. Economic Instability: This includes market volatility, unemployment rates, and interest rates, reflecting the broader economic climate affecting homebuyers.

Garfield County's Challenging Market

Garfield County tops the index with an overall difficulty score of 89.3, making it the toughest place to buy a home in the U.S. Here's a breakdown of the county's scores:

  • Cost: 92.1
  • Competition: 95.8
  • Scarcity: 68.6
  • Economic Instability: 90.1

These scores highlight the extreme challenges prospective homebuyers face in Garfield County, driven by high costs, fierce competition, and economic instability.

Comparing National and Local Trends

Nationally, the Home Buyer Index for April 2024 stands at 82.4, slightly down from its peak of 89.7 in October 2022 but still indicative of a challenging market. Improvements in market competitiveness and the broader economy have somewhat eased conditions over the past year, but high costs and housing shortages continue to keep difficulty levels high.

Why Garfield County?

Garfield County's difficulties stem from a combination of factors unique to the local market. Prices have increased dramatically, driven by limited inventory and high demand. Additionally, the county's popularity as a desirable place to live, with its beautiful natural surroundings and outdoor lifestyle, adds to the competition.

What Does This Mean for Potential Homebuyers?

For those looking to buy a home in Garfield County, it means being prepared for a highly competitive market. Here are a few tips to navigate these challenging conditions:

  1. Get Pre-Approved for a Mortgage: This can give you a competitive edge by showing sellers you are a serious buyer with financing already in place.
  2. Work with a Local Real Estate Agent: An agent with local market knowledge can help you navigate the competitive landscape and find potential opportunities.
  3. Be Ready to Act Quickly: Homes in Garfield County can go under contract quickly, so being prepared to make an offer as soon as you find the right property is crucial.
  4. Consider a Larger Down Payment: Offering a larger down payment can make your offer more attractive to sellers.

Garfield County, with its unparalleled natural beauty and outdoor lifestyle, remains a highly sought-after place to live. However, these same attributes make it the most difficult and competitive housing market in the country. By understanding the challenges and preparing accordingly, potential homebuyers can better navigate the market and find their dream home in this stunning part of Colorado.

If you're considering buying a home in Garfield County including Carbondale, Glenwood Springs, or the surrounding areas, reach out to a knowledgeable local real estate agent who can guide you through the process and help you succeed in this competitive market.


Work With Us

Contact the real estate team at Avant Garde Aspen to sell your property, buy luxury ski property, and browse resort homes for sale in Aspen, Basalt, Carbondale, and the rest of the Roaring Fork Valley.